ISO: Best (Vanilla) Cupcake in Brooklyn???Buttermilk Bakeshop’s vanilla are absolutely heaven! And have the slight cream cheese style frosting (I think, if I recall correctly) similar to carrot cake.
Me want cookies. Cookies are for me.In park slope/gowanus, I like buttermilk bake shop and bearded baker, which has some fun/unusual options (like a cookie stuffed with a Rice Krispie treat).
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyJust brought cake from Buttermilk Bakeshop and it was amazing.
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyWe ordered a cake from Buttermilk Bakery. Delicious!
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyWe brought in cake (Buttermilk) and pizza (La Villa)
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyWe bought a custom cake from Buttermilk Bakeshop—also delicious and beautiful.
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyWe got a rainbow cake from Buttermilk Cake shop - so good!! And beautiful. And we ordered last minute with no problems.
Review from the 2022 Party SurveyAlways delicious and beautiful.
Birthday cupcakes?Buttermilk Bakeshop on 5th Ave is great. They also do vegan and gluten free cakes.
Same-day cake order?Buttermilk Bake Shop on 5th has cakes & will write your happy birthday message in icing on request - I've gotten last-minute bday cakes there a few times, they've always had some available, and they are delicious!
Cupcake recommendation in park slope or Greenwood?Butterly Bakeshop on PPW is fantastic. They did a custom order for my son’s 1st birthday and they couldn’t have been nicer and the cupcakes were delicious.
Cupcake recommendation in park slope or Greenwood?We love buttermilk bake shop on 5th bet Carroll and Garfield.
Vegan cakesClementine Bakery in Clinton Hill and Buttermilk Bakeshop in Park Slope. Clementine will have more flavor varieties since they are all vegan. At Buttermilk, I can highly recommend the vegan vanilla cake with vegan chocolate buttercream frosting.
Vegan cakesIn addition to Clementine, we’ve had luck with the delicious vegan options at Buttermilk Bakeshop in Park Slope.
local bakery making gingerbread house kits?Buttermilk Bakeshop is selling gingerbread house kits, and other holiday-themed assortments!
Where to buy gingerbread house locally?Last year Buttermilk Bakeshop on 5th ave In park slope has delicious kits!
cake for deliveryI highly recommend Buttermilk Bakeshop on 5th Avenue (https://www.buttermilkbakeshop.com/) is a wonderful local bakery and that is doing pickup and delivery. We’ve ordered birthday cakes in the past and they are incredible.
2020 Birthday Party Survey responseWe brought a cake from Buttermilk (it was delicious) and special plates/napkins for dessert.
2020 Birthday Party Survey responseIf you bought, catered or ordered other food, where did you order from and how was it? Cake from Buttermilk was fantastic.
2020 Birthday Party Survey responseIf you bought, catered or ordered other food, where did you order from and how was it? custom Cake from buttermilk bakeshop. it was good
ISO: Birthday Party CakesWe always buy ours at Buttermilk Bake Shop. You can mix and match fillings and cakes to create whatever you want and they look classically festive. I find their serving sizes to be a little overblown with the way most adults eat cake today, so you can size down from their recommendations... or don't. The cakes freeze well, and we keep slices in our freezer for days we want a fun dessert.
Gluten Free 1st Birthday CakeYes I’ve had gluten free cupcakes from buttermilk and they’re delicious!
Gluten Free 1st Birthday CakeI recently ordered a gluten-free cake from buttermilk bakery and was pleasantly surprised how good it was. It’s on fifth Avenue in Park Slope. I would give them a call.
Bakeries in Park Slope ??Buttermilk did a great job for our wedding cake.
CookiesWe love the cookies at Buttermilk Bakeshop. They are our go-to host gift when we visit with friends. They cookies are big enough that they will be similar to having cupcakes for all the guests if that's what you're looking for. The snickerdoodle is a particular favorite of ours.
Themed CupcakesWe really love Buttermilk Bakeshop. We usually get the mini cupcakes when ordering a bunch just because they are so cute and they let you mix and match flavors.
Picture transfer cakeButtermilk Bakeshop does them and I love their cakes. And if you want ice cream, I believe Ice Cream House in Kensington does ice cream cakes with transferred photos. I’ve never had a cake from there but I have had the ice cream and it’s pretty good. It’s kosher/in an Orthodox section of Kensington so won’t be open Friday afternoon or Saturday. I would go in to order; their web presence is kind of sketchy. Enjoy!
2018 ReviewAnother vote for buttermilk bakeshop! Fast, reasonably priced and delicious. Love their funfetti flavor with buttercream frosting.
2018 ReviewWe had an amazing experience with Buttermilk Bakeshop in Park Slope! Their cakes are amazing, they worked super quickly and they are very reasonably priced for their product.
2018 Birthday Party ReviewBirthday cakes from Buttermilk Bakeshop are always a winner, and reasonable priced for the quality.
2018 Birthday Party ReviewThe cake had rave reviews with funfetti and vanilla buttercream. The design of the cake turned out slightly different than I expected, but all in all great choice. They even made a mini cake for the birthday boy that matched the large cake.
Shout out to Buttermilk BakeryI also want to give them a huge shout out for their custom made cupcakes for our son’s 5th birthday. They tasted great and the custom design was incredibly fairly priced compared to other bakeries I contacted.
Shout out to Buttermilk BakeryI just had my son's 7th birthday party at Buttermilk Bakery on 5th Ave and it was AWESOME!! My son and his friends made cupcakes and decorated them. He was so happy. Each child had a chance to crack eggs, beat the batter, and put on their own frosting! The staff made everything really easy. My son is already planning next year's birthday party there!
Good chocolate cake in the slope?I got a chocolate cake from Buttermilk Bake Shop and it was AMAZING (Review submitted April 2017)
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 6 Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cake Birthday Cake Review: This was the second year in a row I'd gotten the cake from Buttermilk, because it's simply the best birthday cake I've ever had. The traditional white birthday cake with white icing is incredibly dense and moist. Also, they did a perfect design exactly to my specs.
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: one 4 years old, one 7 years old Birthday Cake Type: a photo or theme cake Birthday Cake Review: We have gotten many cakes from Buttermilk and they are always great. We actually prefer them to their cupcakes! They do amazing graphics and made us a wonderful bowling themed cake.
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 3 Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cake Birthday Cake Review: great, but was sad to discover they couldn't do a dairy-free cake without going full vegan. (they used to)
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 5 Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cake Birthday Cake Review: We only order from Buttermilk. They make the BEST cakes!!
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 2 Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cake Birthday Cake Review: It was really good. No complaints here
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 6 Birthday Cake Type: allergy or gluten-free Birthday Cake Review: Great
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 4 Birthday Cake Type: a photo or theme cake Birthday Cake Review: Delicious!! Customized and decorated like our theme, very pleased.
Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016Age of child: 3 Birthday Cake Type: a photo or theme cake Birthday Cake Review: Great
Review of Buttermilk BakeryI highly recommend Buttermilk Bakery for your birthday cake needs. I wanted a nice medium sized ladybug cake, everywhere else wanted hundreds of dollars for this request. Buttermilk's folks were very communicative, they asked me to describe it, send pictures of what I wanted and voila! it was done. Let them do the hard work of baking, you enjoy the party.
Re: 7th Ave Stores and Businesses you LOVE?We love Buttermilk for tasty treats.
Some of the listing features are available only for registered users. Please login to view all listing details!