Entry Detail

    Fairway in Red Hook
    Street:
    (for not-fancy sheet cake)
    Neighborhood:
    Red Hook

    Review and Rating

    Reviewed by 2018Review
    On 14-Aug-2018
    Subject:  Sheet Cake Recs
    Comment:  Huge fan of Fairway’s cakes. Red Hook. Affordable and tasty. I’ve asked them each time to decrease the amount of sugar they use and the result has been to my liking.
    Reviewed by 2017Review
    On 11-Jun-2017
    Subject:  first birthday cake recommendations
    Comment:  I’ve had good luck with Fairway’s cakes as well in terms of quality / taste. However, if you are looking for a unique custom design, they unfortunately use your preferences as “inspiration” and end up doing their own thing. But they have a wide collection of designs they are comfortable doing per their book.
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 08-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 5Review: Picked up food from the catering menu at Fairway-great/reasonable pricing
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 04-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 3Birthday Cake Type: cupcakesBirthday Cake Review: Decent if you choose their Fairway Market decorated cupcakes.
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 27-Aug-2016
    Subject:  Photo Cakes?
    Comment:  We got ours at fairway and it was both tasty and reasonably priced. I did a bunch of research before ordering and this seemed to be the best option. Nice to work with also!
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 27-Aug-2016
    Subject:  Photo Cakes?
    Comment:  We got our son's photo cake there the last 3 years it looked good and tasted yummy!
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 27-Aug-2016
    Subject:   Photo Cakes?
    Comment:  Yes Fairway photo cakes are yummy. Suggest the buttercream frosting. We've gotten at least 6 photo cakes from them over the years.
    Reviewed by Administrator
    On 21-Apr-2013
    Subject:  Re: Need recommendation for a cake
    Comment:  I just want to caution that Fairway, as much as I love them as a grocery store, really messed up a large cupcake order for us. When we arrived at pick up time, they appeared to have completely lost the order. They had absolutely no cupcakes anywhere in sight. They looked bewildered when we arrived and said what we were there for. Â (Amazing, because they usually have a good amount of cupcakes on display.)When I showed them my receipt for the order, with the pickup date/time noted, they scrambled to throw together an assortment of cupcakes, probably day-olds, none of which were the flavor / color / decoration that we ordered. Â They have not received any more special occasion bakery orders from us.
    Reviewed by Administrator
    On 21-Apr-2013
    Subject:  Re: Need recommendation for a cake
    Comment:  Fairway Catering. Great cake, they deliver, very reasonable (more than Costco, much less than bakeries.)
    Reviewed by PSPMemberReview
    On 21-Feb-2012
    Subject:  Recommend with Reservations
    Comment:  The cake looked beautiful with Dora on it - but didn't taste that great..which was surprising because I love Fairway. I don't think I would use them again. (2012 Birthday Party Survey)
    Reviewed by PSPMemberReview
    On 21-Feb-2012
    Subject:  Highly Recommend