Entry Detail

    Review and Rating

    Reviewed by 2017Review
    On 30-Jul-2017
    Subject:  Re: ISO: Last minute delicious cake
    Comment:  I had a an amazing birthday cake made by 4 Wish Cakery on a very short notice. It looked exactly as we imagined it and tasted great. Janna was very nice and accommodating.
    Reviewed by 2017Review
    On 06-May-2017
    Subject:  Re: ISO - Rainbow Layer Cake
    Comment:  Try Janna Bastone at Four Wishes Cakery – she’s on Montgomery Place and does custom cakes, including things more complicated than this, and they’re delicious! (Review submitted April 2017)
    Reviewed by 2017Review
    On 06-May-2017
    Subject:  Good chocolate cake in the slope?
    Comment:  I absolutely second this recommendation! We get all of our cakes made by Jana!! (Review submitted April 2017)
    Reviewed by 2017Review
    On 06-May-2017
    Subject:  Good chocolate cake in the slope?
    Comment:  4 wishes cakery does an amazing chocolate cake! Janna will work with you to get exactly what you want. Highly recommended!We did a chocolate cake 2 years ago for my daughter's birthday with absolutely no leftovers due to requests for seconds. We did a red velvet the following year which was equally delicious. Reasonably priced and delivery is possible.(Review submitted April 2017)
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 04-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 8Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cakeBirthday Cake Review: Amazing-- great design and super tasty. Baker will work with ingredient preferences. My favorite cakes ever!!
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 04-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 2Birthday Cake Type: a photo or theme cakeBirthday Cake Review: Perfect and delicious
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 04-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 3Birthday Cake Type: traditional birthday cakeBirthday Cake Review: Delicious and so adorable. The owner , Janna, is so pleasant and creative. The cakes are reasonably priced and she delivers in Park Skope for a nominal fee.
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 04-Dec-2016
    Subject:  Review from Kids Birthday and Bar/Bat Mitzvah Party Survey - 2016
    Comment:  Age of child: 7Birthday Cake Type: a photo or theme cakeBirthday Cake Review: The owner made a character cake for my son. A big hit at the party!!!
    Reviewed by 2016Review
    On 20-Feb-2016
    Subject:  Re: Cake maker?
    Comment:  We use Janna Bastone at 3 Wishes Cakery for my daughter’s birthday every year. Her first cake for us was an extraordinary minion cake. This year (tomorrow in fact) we’re getting a cookie cake. So far, there’s nothing we’ve asked for that she could not make for our daughter. I can’t recommend her enough.
    Reviewed by
    On 11-Dec-2014
    Subject:  Seeking: specialty cake, Minecraft
    Comment:  I highly recommend Janna Bastone and 4 Wishes Cakery. She did a wonderful job for my daughter’s 10th birthday and I’m getting ready to place my order for her 11th. The cakes she made were beautiful and delicious! Part of the proceeds you pay her get donated to a charity of your choice, too!(November 2014)
    Reviewed by
    On 07-Dec-2014
    Subject:  Shout out for 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  > I want to give a HUGE shout out to Janna Bastone at 4 Wishes Cakery. Janna made a car cake for my husband's birthday which she made based off a photo I sent her. It not only looked exactly like his car, it was unbelievably delicious (and VERY affordable-cake for 12-20 at $65)! I also want to make mention of something unique to Janna's company, which is the 4th wish portion. She donates a portion of the sale to a charity. Not only is she a wonderful baker, but a great communicator and generous human. > I can't wait for our next special occasion where we will definitely be using Janna again!(November 2014)
    Reviewed by
    On 13-Mar-2014
    Subject:   Back Birthday cake recommendations
    Comment:  Janna Bastone is amazing. She did great work (cupcakes and 2 cakes) for my daughter’s 10th birthday.
    Reviewed by
    On 15-Feb-2014
    Subject:  Shout out to 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  I also recommend her! Great cupcakes for my 3 yr old's birthday. The banana peanut butter was outstanding! My husband liked it so much he even requested his birthday cake from her. Great business
    Reviewed by
    On 15-Feb-2014
    Subject:  Shout out to 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  Same here!!! She made beautiful cupcakes for my son's birthday. Highly recommended!
    Reviewed by
    On 15-Feb-2014
    Subject:  Shout out to 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  Just have to chime in here, too! Last summer Janna made a delicious and incredible cake for our kid's birthday. We needed a cake (not cupcakes) and wanted it to incorporate our Elephant & Piggie theme. But we thought a full cake in the shape of the characters would be a bit over the top. Janna was super flexible and made the characters out of cupcakes, with the characters sitting on the top of a regular cake. It was adorable and looked just right, and was a very modest price for being so tailored to what we wanted. The kids loved it!!I am also not affiliated with Janna in any way, and also very appreciative!
    Reviewed by
    On 15-Feb-2014
    Subject:  Shout out to 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  I'd just like to second this recommendation -- Janna did a slew of assorted mini cupcakes for my husband's birthday this past fall. I'm a baker myself but this was a surprise party so there was no way I could make them myself in secret (and also no way I would have had the patience to make the five different varieties she did for me!) -- but I wanted to taste and look great -- and they did!Highly recommended and a pleasure to work with Janna!
    Reviewed by
    On 15-Feb-2014
    Subject:  Shout out to 4 Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  I recently used Janna Bastone to make cupcakes and cakes for my daughter’s birthday. Someone from PSP emailed me her information when I posted looking for a minion cake. She was very responsive and was able to get everything done quickly for me. Everyone loved not just the looks of the cakes and cupcakes, but they were delicious as well. It was easy to work with her and she really cared about making my daughter’s wishes come true.The quality of her designs and cakes are excellent. Her prices are reasonable. And I love that a portion of what she charges gets donated to charity. She gives you a list of charities to choose from.So if you need a cake, consider 4 Wishes Cakery.P.S. I’m not affiliated with her at all. I’m just a happy customer with a very happy tween.
    Reviewed by Administrator
    On 25-Aug-2013
    Subject:  Thank you - Not too sweet cake
    Comment:  Janna Bastone of 4 Wishes Cakery can customize any cake to any taste buds, and is super reasonably priced.
    Reviewed by Administrator
    On 30-Jul-2013
    Subject:  Re: ISO Elephant and Piggie Cake/cupcakes
    Comment:  Janna Bastone of 4 Wishes Cakery (4wishescakery.com) just made a phenomenal cake for my son's 3rd birthday. Gorgeous AND delicious. I'm still fielding emails about the cake. I'm convinced she can do anything!
    Reviewed by Administrator
    On 17-Jun-2013
    Subject:  Four Wishes Cakery
    Comment:  We had cupcakes donated to a Friends of the Park Slope Library event and they were wonderful! She made us specialized mermaid cupcakes in honor of a book reading about the mermaid parade. They came perfectly packaged so they could travel, they were fabulous tasting, and Janna was a pleasure to work with! She’s a local mom to a tween kid doing it all! LOVE supporting local great people! Highly recommend!